Dubious Provenance starts from the bag in your Bayside apartment closet. Drive to Evelyn Andrews Antiques in Capri, where Benedict Halifax offers to appraise the statue and leaves his watch as collateral if you agree. That first part is all the story needs. Two optional follow-up parts come later in Chapter 3 and pay out roughly $2,500 in loot plus a '32 Hustler.
Before you start
Dubious Provenance (Visit the Antique Store) unlocks after Dealer’s Choice. Start it by interacting with the bag in the closet of your Bayside apartment. Jason and Lucia want someone to tell them what the statue from Chapter 2 is really worth, so they take it to Evelyn Andrews, who owns the antique store in Capri. Her colleague Benedict Halifax is a British antiques dealer.
The mission comes in three parts, and you play it as both Jason and Lucia. Only the first part is needed for the story. Parts 2 and 3 arrive later in Chapter 3 and are where the rewards are.

Steps
Part 1: Visit the Antique Store
- Go to Capri. The town is at the far west of the map. Drive, or book a RideMe to save time.
- Try the front door. A scene plays upstairs. Evelyn decides the statue is either a remarkable fake or stolen and won’t touch it. Halifax offers to appraise it quietly instead.
- Decide on the offer. Agree and he leaves you his Crowex Octane “Bobby Ambrose” watch as collateral. Wear it from any wardrobe under Accessories > Watches.
- Explore Capri (optional). The objective clears as soon as you visit a shop or leave town. You don’t have to do anything.
- Call Halifax (optional). This only applies if you said no. Calling him later hands over the statue and unlocks the next part the same way.
Part 2: Find Halifax
- Return to the store. Halifax has gone quiet, so head back to Capri. Time passes while you wait for Evelyn to leave.
- Get inside. You can break the door down, but the quiet way is round the back: up the stairs, across to the lower roof, then through the window above the air conditioning unit.
- Let Jason in. Walk to the door and it opens for him.
- Search the office. Look around if you like. The key item is the drawer of the desk in the north corner.
- Check the motel next door. A resident points you to an upstairs room on the west side. Knock on the door.
- Make the call. After the scene you choose whether to trust Halifax. Only trusting him leads to Part 3.


Part 3: Speak with Evelyn
- See Evelyn. She calls with news. Go back to the store and she gives you an address in the north-west part of town.
- Chase on the water. Halifax runs for a boat. Jason grabs a Seashark. Pull alongside and hold Square/X to jump aboard.
- Chase on land. The boat crashes and he runs. Swim ashore and follow him. When he drives off in a golf cart, take the bike standing in the yard.
- Stop him as Lucia. Halifax pepper-sprays Jason, and the game switches to Lucia as he runs into her car. Jump out, use focus (L3 + R3) and shoot him in the leg.
- Call Jason. Walk up to Halifax so he gives up, then open Lucia’s phone and call Jason.
- Choose his fate. You can shoot or spare him. Either way, you then have the statue back.
Rewards
- Part 1: the Crowex Octane “Bobby Ambrose” watch, if you accept the deal.
- Part 3: about $2,500 in jewellery and cash from the storage container, plus the ‘32 Hustler, which you can keep or sell.
What comes next
If you haven’t yet, play Lucia’s Mami Knows Best. Part 2 of this mission shows up on the map as Find Halifax a while after he gets the statue. Part 3 (Speak with Evelyn) starts when Evelyn calls.
FAQ
Should you give Halifax the statue?
Accepting gets you his Crowex Octane "Bobby Ambrose" watch right away and moves the mission on. If you decline, you get an optional objective to call him later and hand it over, which leads to the same follow-ups.
Can you miss parts 2 and 3 of Dubious Provenance?
Yes. If Halifax never gets the statue, the call-back objective disappears when Chapter 3 ends and the follow-ups are gone. They aren't needed for the story or 100% completion, but you lose the loot and the car.
How do you get into the antique store quietly?
Go round the back, climb the stairs and jump across to the lower roof. From there, climb into the window above the air conditioning unit, then open the door for Jason.